Do I Still Need a Lawyer If the Insurance Company Admits Fault After My Alabama Car Accident?
In many cases, yes, because an insurance company that accepts liability is only agreeing that its driver caused the wreck. What your injuries are worth is still open to dispute. Your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering can all be challenged, and the adjuster handling your claim works for the company that has to pay it.
Attorney J. David Greene of Greene & Phillips Injury Lawyers covered this on a recent episode of WKRG News 5’s Judge Knows, explaining why hearing “we accept liability” from an adjuster doesn’t mean the hard part is over.
What Does It Mean When an Insurance Company Accepts Liability?
It means the insurer agrees its driver was at fault for the crash. That’s useful, because it takes the argument over who ran the light or who followed too closely off the table. But fault is only half of an injury claim. The other half is damages, meaning what the wreck actually cost you, and that’s where most of the fighting happens.
“We accept liability” can also cover less than it sounds like. Sometimes it means the insurer will pay to fix your car. Sometimes it means an adjuster calls and says to send in your medical bills and they’ll take care of them. That sounds generous. David’s point is that the offer leaves out most of what an injury claim can include, and even the bills you send in will get picked apart.
What Can the Insurance Company Still Dispute After Admitting Fault?
Almost everything that decides how much you’re paid. Even with fault settled, an adjuster can argue:
- That some of your medical charges were unnecessary or too high. Bills often get reviewed line by line.
- That a crash like yours couldn’t have caused the injury you’re being treated for.
- That your pain comes from a condition you had before the wreck.
- That your claim is worth far less than you think it is.
So an insurer can agree to pay for your property damage and, in the same conversation, take the position that your injuries don’t fit what happened in the collision.
Why Does the Insurance Company Keep Asking About Old Injuries?
Because almost everyone has some. David noted that most adults past 30 have some wear and tear in the spine, knees, or ankles, and things like degenerative disc disease show up on plenty of scans of people who never had a problem until a wreck. Insurers know this, and they’ll point to it as the “real” cause of your symptoms.
An old condition doesn’t rule out a claim. If the crash made it worse, that harm can still be part of what you recover. We wrote more about this in Can I Still File a Claim If I Had a Pre-Existing Condition Before My Alabama Car Accident?
Should I Sign a Medical Release From the Other Driver’s Insurance Company?
Not before you talk to a lawyer. Adjusters often ask injured people to sign a blanket medical authorization, which can let the insurer request years of records from your doctors, including visits that have nothing to do with the wreck. David described insurers trying to pull five years of medical history this way. His advice on signing one was short: don’t.
The insurer will eventually need records tied to your crash injuries. A lawyer can provide those without opening up your whole medical history for the adjuster to search.
What Does Paying My Medical Bills Leave Out?
Quite a lot. An Alabama car accident claim can include more than the bills you’ve already received, such as:
- Pain and suffering
- Lost wages from missed work
- Future medical treatment
- Future pain and suffering
An offer to cover medical bills usually doesn’t account for any of these. Once you sign a settlement release, your claim is generally over, even if your treatment isn’t. That’s why it helps to have someone look at the full picture before you agree to anything.
What Does a Lawyer Do If It’s Already Clear I Wasn’t at Fault?
Builds the rest of the case. Admitted fault doesn’t prove your damages, so the work shifts to showing what the wreck did to you. At Greene & Phillips, that means investigating the crash, getting witness statements, speaking with the troopers or officers who worked the wreck, and gathering the medical proof that connects your injuries to the collision. The firm’s investigators include people with law enforcement experience.
A lawyer can also evaluate what your claim may be worth based on your injuries, treatment, and lost income. As David put it, that’s not a number the insurance company should be setting for you. Greene & Phillips has handled personal injury claims since 1998.
How Long Do I Have to File a Car Accident Claim in Alabama?
In most car accident injury cases, Alabama gives you two years from the date of the wreck to file a lawsuit. Some situations have different deadlines, including claims against a city or other government entity, so it’s worth asking a lawyer early. An insurer accepting fault doesn’t pause that clock.
What Should I Do If the Adjuster Has Already Called?
Hold off on signing anything. Keep any letters, emails, or texts from the insurance company, write down what the adjuster told you, and talk with a lawyer before you sign a medical authorization or accept a settlement check.
If an insurance company has told you it accepts fault for your wreck, call Greene & Phillips Injury Lawyers at 251-478-1115 (Mobile) or 205-918-7800 (Birmingham), or visit our contact page. You can also stop by our Midtown Mobile office at 51 N Florida St or our Birmingham office in the Watts Building at 301 20th St N. No appointment needed. The initial consultation is free, and cases are handled on a contingency fee basis: if there’s no recovery, you owe no attorney fee and no case expenses. If there is a recovery, case expenses are paid from it separately from the attorney fee.

